Analysis

Will VCs stand out from the crowd?

Source: UK unquote | 09 Nov 2012
Crowd funding could compete with venture capital for deals

With crowd-funding service Kickstarter seeing its UK launch last week, entrepreneurs and venture capitalists may wish to consider the role of this new democratised form of financing in the investment landscape. John Bakie reports

The concept behind Kickstarter is simple. Post your business idea online, set a "pledge goal" and offer your products and bonus materials to people who provide cash to back your business. Kickstarter, which takes a 5% cut of the money pledged, has so far helped raise over $300m for projects as varied as music acts and video games to a statue of Robocop for the city of Detroit.

In return for donations, most projects are offering a special incentive. For example, if you donate $20 to a film project you might get a DVD, maybe for $30 it will be signed by the cast, or $100 gets you a package full of related merchandise. Kickstarter has demonstrated that users are willing to put big money to get exclusive content and play a role in a product's development from the beginning. One such example is videogame Project Eternity, which has raised almost $4m on Kickstarter, including five eager backers who put down $10,000 each to attend the official launch event and have a role in designing aspects of the game.

So what does this mean for venture capital investors? Well, for an entrepreneur who is protective of his equity, crowd-funding projects through services like Kickstarter could be a viable alternative to seeking seed finance from an institutional investor. Under the Kickstarter system, backers only receive items, not equity. This could be very attractive for a number of entrepreneurs who may feel they do not get good value when they sell equity to a VC.

For businesses that need a relatively small amount of start-up cash, the crowd-funding model has a number of advantages. Firstly, capital can be raised relatively quickly. The entrepreneurs can simply upload information about the project and set their deadline – usually a few months – and can then market their idea to generate interest and pledges. By contrast, approaching VCs, making a pitch and then negotiating the exact details of the deal can be a lengthy and complex process, particularly for the inexperienced.

However, crowd funding also has its drawbacks. Firstly, as the funders hold no equity, they have no long-term interest in the future of the business, and cannot or will not offer the kind of invaluable business guidance that can come from an experienced VC investor. Also, the Kickstarter model focuses very much on the immediate funding needs of a business. If, some months down the line, an entrepreneur finds they did not raise enough, or they wish to expand the scope of their development, they will not be able to return to their investors for additional funding, wheras a VC backer is far more able to provide funding or advice to capitalise on additional opportunities.

So, while Kickstarter's UK launch is likely to attract a number of entrepreneurs looking to develop their business idea through crowd funding, the VC community should continue to remind budding business people that this model has its weaknesses. While it might suit some business concepts, it simply cannot offer the same long-term backing, and crucial business experience that a professional venture capitalist brings to the table.

Visitor Comments

 

Add your comment

We won't publish your address
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

Your comment will be moderated before publication.

search unquote.com

Industry news

Gimv makes 1.3x return on divestments for 2012/13

Gimv has announced a 1.3x return on divestments, relative to original acquisition value, for the year ending in March 2013.

Benelux unquote

| 24 May 2013 | secure

3i to buy Barclays’ infrastructure fund management business

3i has made a binding offer to buy Barclays’ European infrastructure fund management business.

UK unquote

| 24 May 2013 | secure

Diana sale could yield €1bn for Axa PE

Axa Private Equity is mulling a sale for French food ingredients business Diana Ingredients, according to reports.

France unquote

| 24 May 2013 | secure

EU postpones Solvency II rules on pensions

The European Commission has postponed a bid to apply Solvency II style rules to pension funds as part of the revised IORP Directive.

unquote

| 24 May 2013 | secure

Regions

Event

event

unquote" British Private Equity Awards 2013

Date: 03 Oct 2013

Location: London, UK

event

unquote" DACH Private Equity Forum

Date: 10 Oct 2013

Location: Munich, Germany

event

unquote" Italia Private Equity Forum

Date: 12 Nov 2013

Location: Milan, Italy

Updating your subscription status Loading

Digital Editions

Unquote Analysis DACH Cover

DACH unquote” May 2013

CVC’s €3bn buy-back of Ista in April caused much excitement for German private equity in 2013, though a deeper look at the figures......

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis France Cover

France unquote” May 2013

“Some key ideas are currently gaining ground,” said Afic chairman Louis Godron at the association’s annual conference in Paris......

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis UK Cover

UK & Ireland unquote” May 2013

The UK & Ireland’s first quarter activity levels are at their lowest level for the past five years, according to the latest research......

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis Nordics Cover

Nordic unquote" May 2013

For almost 40 years, Sweden was one of the few countries in the world where private retail of pharmaceuticals was banned.

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis SE Cover

Southern Europe unquote” May 2013

Italian businesses are struggling. In the first quarter of the year, 4,218 Italian firms went bankrupt according to financial newspaper......

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis CEE cover

CEE unquote” April 2013

It’s official: Central and Eastern Europe is unsexy. It is the least desirable geography for family offices to invest in, according......

More digital editions

Unquote Analysis Benelux Cover

Benelux unquote" April 2013

Exits have dominated the Benelux market in the past month, but the disposals were not all good news for private equity in the region.......

More digital editions

Events

event

unquote" British Private Equity Awards 2013

Date: 03 Oct 2013
Location: London, UK
event

unquote" DACH Private Equity Forum

Date: 10 Oct 2013
Location: Munich, Germany
event

unquote" Italia Private Equity Forum

Date: 12 Nov 2013
Location: Milan, Italy

Email Alerts