The irrelevance of fees

Source: unquote | 06 Nov 2012
Standard management fees for large-cap funds remain controversial

LPs are not forced to back private equity, they choose to – fees and all. Kimberly Romaine questions the impact of LP rants.

There has been much debate over industry fees since the BVCA's annual summit, where Sandra Robertson of Oxford University Endowment Management used her speaking slot to criticise the industry, suggesting the inflated fees were not justified by returns, which currently mirror those of the FTSE 250 or a bond index, yet with none of the liquidity. Indeed Carlyle's William Conway Jr had said just minutes earlier that returns would be lower in years to come owing to the market malaise that is hampering growth and lending.

It's not just private equity struggling to maintain performance; last week, hedge fund guru Geoff Grant, of Goldman pedigree, wrote to investors to say he no longer had an "edge" in today's market and so would wind the fund up. The announcement came just weeks after emerging markets investor Greg Coffey stepped out of the investment spotlight aged just 41. And within private equity, some big names are bowing out: CVC chairman Michael Smith stepped down last week.

Is the golden age behind us, with all the sacrosanct industry luminaries heading for the exit to escape an apocalypse of downward-spiralling returns and beefed-up fees to compensate the heavy-lifters?


But now more than ever it is about fund manager selection. GPs should sell themselves more, and the industry less. This is particularly true for venture, but increasingly so for buyout funds. Yes, the bottom performers lose investors lots of money, and charge for the privilege. But the averages and means are brought up by vehicles very deserving of capital and whose fees are justified by the queues of investors trying to get in. It is basic supply and demand. Even Robertson paid lip-service to this small group.

The Endowment Robertson manages was itself scrutinised by a 2010 article in The Independent, suggesting the fees charged (just under £700,000 paid by its colleges in 2009 – roughly equal to her compensation that year, according to the article) may have been overzealous given the fact £50m had been lost that year. She declined to comment, other than to say the article had been withdrawn.

The true intention of Robertson's diatribe will only ever be fully known by her; it's certainly cast the spotlight on her on the day itself as well as weeks after, with a handful of letters published in the FT. But LPs that whinge about fees should only be taken seriously when they no longer accept investment proposal meetings.

Visitor Comments


Add your comment

We won't publish your address
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

Your comment will be moderated before publication.


Industry news

CVC's Backman named CEO of Finnish Industry Investment

Backman replaces Juha Marjosola, who takes senior adviser role

Nordic unquote

| 29 Aug 2014 | secure

BGF appoints north-UK talent network manager

BGF appoints north-UK talent network manager

Victoria Robson, Business Growth fund

UK unquote

| 29 Aug 2014 | secure

DHB sale to face regulatory scrutiny

Strategic buyers are preferred by regulators according to credit agency Fitch

DACH unquote

| 28 Aug 2014 | secure

Ropes & Gray appoints Travers Smith's Sanderson

Mid-market M&A specialist joins as partner in London office


| 27 Aug 2014 | secure

Updating your subscription status Loading


Victoria Robson of BGF

Victoria Robson, Business Growth fund

More people news

Steve Cockell of RBS

Steve Cockell, RBS

RBS has named Steve Cockell as head of London origination

More people news

Sarah Ledwidge of Business Growth Fund

Business Growth Fund (BGF) has appointed Sarah Ledwidge as investment manager in its Bristol Office

More people news

Sam Archer of Downing

Downing has appointed Sam Archer as investment director in its unquoted investment team.

More people news

Oliver Felsenstein of Clifford Chance

Oliver Felsenstein, Clifford Chance

Clifford Chance has promoted Oliver Felsenstein to head of corporate advisory in the company’s German office

More people news



unquote British Private Equity Awards

Date: 02 Oct 2014
Location: London, UK

unquote" DACH Private Equity Forum

Date: 07 Oct 2014
Location: Munich, Germany

unquote" Italia Private Equity Forum

Date: 12 Nov 2014
Location: Milan, Italy

Forum unquote” Italia sul Private Equity

Date: 12 Nov 2014
Location: Milan, Italy

Chartis Report: Operational Risk Management Systems for Financial Services 2013

This report covers the specific technologies required for firms to improve their ORM processes.


The optimization of everything: OTC derivatives, counterparty credit risk and funding

The global financial crisis has created much excitement over counterparty credit risk (CCR) and, in recognition of this, banks have been improving their practices around CCR.

Email Alerts